0.4 seconds: Derek Fisher
In 2004 Derek Fisher proved that he’s the greatest basketball player in a 0.4 second timespan. In game 5 of the western conference semifinals, Tim Duncan made a long 2 pointer to give the Spurs a 73-72 lead with 0.4 seconds left. Classic early 2000’s Spurs score. The series was tied 2-2, so this was a very pivotal game. Either the Lakers or the Spurs had won all 5 of the post-Bulls-dynasty championships at this point, and they both had a legitimate chance at winning the title in 2004.
After 3 timeouts, 2 substitutions from the Spurs, and different inbound formations from the Lakers, they were finally ready to inbound the ball. Now, the Lakers had 4 all-time great players on the court: Shaquille O’Neal, Kobe Bryant, Karl Malone, and Gary Payton. Throughout the course of their careers, they would combine for 56 all-star selections. Their 5th player was Derek Fisher, a player who amassed 0 all-star selections. And yet, he was the one to rise to the occasion. Payton looked for Kobe, who was double-teamed. A long lob to Shaq seemed improbable, and Karl Malone was just standing around. So Payton threw the ball to Fisher, and in one fluid motion, Derek caught the ball, turned and shot it. The buzzer sounded, the ball went in, the Lakers won the game, and Fisher cemented himself as the greatest basketball player for 0.4 seconds.
1 second: Rasheed Wallace
There are many contenders for the greatest basketball player for one second. Kobe Bryant comes to mind, catching the inbound and making a fadeaway three against the Blazers to win the final game of the season.
My pick is Rasheed Wallace. It was the March 26th, 2007 game between the Denver Nuggets and the Detroit Pistons. The Nuggets were up 3 with the ball out of bounds, at halfcourt, with 1.5 seconds on the clock. That is a very good situation for the Nuggets. What would have to go wrong in order for the Pistons to win this game?
Statistically speaking, NBA teams are extremely good at inbounding the ball safely when they absolutely need to. Teams are usually able to inbound the ball to a good free throw shooter. Good free throw shooters shoot around/above 80% from the line. So either the Pistons would have to immediately foul a Nuggets player, hope that he misses both free throws [4% chance], then get the rebound and throw up a 90 foot prayer at the buzzer, OR they’d have to steal the inbound pass and make a three in one clean motion.
That’s exactly what happened. The inbound pass was tipped, Rasheed Wallace stole the ball beyond half court with 1.0 seconds left, turned and shot from sixty feet away, banking in the 3 to send the game into overtime. A beautiful play. A steal and 3 points in 1 second. That’s impressive. Ball don’t lie!
9 seconds: Reggie Miller
In game 1 of the 1995 eastern conference semifinals, the Knicks had a 105-99 lead over the Pacers with 18.7 seconds left. Mark Jackson passed the ball into Reggie Miller, who immediately launched a three, sinking it with 16.4 seconds left. The Knicks’ Anthony Mason couldn’t find any teammate on the inbound, so he made a weak pass, which was caught by Miller. He raced back behind the three-point line and drilled his second consecutive three, tying the game at 105 with 13.2 seconds left. That’s 6 points in 3.2 seconds, or 1.875 points per second.
Knicks guard John Starks gets fouled on the inbound pass. As commentator Bill Waton noted, there was “no need to foul in that situation,” considering the game was tied. Typically teams will just try to get one last stop.
Anyway, Starks, a 73.7% free throw shooter that season, missed BOTH free throws. That’s great for the Pacers! But then Patrick Ewing, the Knicks’ best player, secured the offensive rebound. He shot it, missed, and Reggie Miller was fouled on the next rebound with 7.5 seconds left. Reggie, an 89.7% free throw shooter, sunk both shots, thus scoring 8 points in 8.9 seconds. The Knicks failed to get a shot off, and the Pacers won the game.
Reggie Miller was the greatest basketball player for 9 seconds.
35 seconds: Tracy McGrady
On December 9th, 2004, the Houston Rockets trailed the prime-Duncan-led Spurs 68 to 76 in the final minute of the game. Another classic 2004 Spurs score. McGrady made a three to cut the deficit to 5 with 35 seconds left. The Rockets intentionally fouled Devin Brown, who made 2 free throws. McGrady then brought the ball up, pump faked, and drew a foul on perennial DPOY candidate Tim Duncan, sinking another three in the process. McGrady completed the 4 point play, making the Rockets’ only free throw in the quarter. The score was now 78-75.
After running some time off the clock, Tim Duncan was finally fouled with 16.2 seconds left. Duncan also made his 2 free throws. After a timeout, the Rockets barely made the inbound into McGrady, who dribbled and drained another contested three over another DPOY candidate, Bruce Bowen.
The Spurs passed the ball into Devin Brown, who fell to the floor, losing the ball. It was picked up by, you guessed it, Tracy McGrady. He dribbled up the court and made, you guessed it, another contested three pointer. The Spurs failed to score in the final seconds, and the Rockets won 81-80.
It was incredible, amazing, phenomenal! It showcased how powerful offense can be. As good and as important as defense is, the best offense just wins. You can never really force a guy to miss a shot. If a guy like T-Mac is just gonna make four three’s in a row, you can’t stop it.
Just for fun, if we extrapolate his 35-second stats to 40 minutes [what McGrady averaged that season], he would score 891 points and grab 68 steals. That’s a good game!
1 quarter: Klay Thompson
The best basketball player in a one-quarter time frame was Klay Thompson on January 23rd, 2015. It was the third quarter of a game between the Golden State Warriors and the Sacramento Kings. Klay went off, to put it mildly. He scored 37 points in the 12 minute period, an NBA record. The man could not miss at all. He made everything. He went 9 for 9 from three point range, which would be an incredible feat for an entire game. He went 13/13 overall from the field and 2/2 from the free throw line.
We talk about players being “in the zone,” and this is the most “in the zone” a player has ever been. If this mystical zone does in fact exist, Klay Thompson has been there, and he’s been there more completely than any other basketball player.
1 game: Wilt Chamberlain
The greatest basketball player over the course of one game was Wilt Chamberlain on March 2nd, 1962. The game took place in Hershey, Pennsylvania between the Philadelphia Warriors and the New York Knicks. The day before the game, Wilt stayed up all night partying with a young woman in New York City, as Wilt is inclined to do. He almost missed the bus to the Hershey Sports Arena, but once he got there, he cemented himself as the greatest basketball player for a single game.
He scored 100 points, shattering his previous record of 78 from earlier that year. That 78 required triple overtime, whereas the 100 was accomplished in regulation.
100-point game doubters/deniers are quickly becoming the most annoying subset of NBA fans. It’s always the same: “we have footage of ____ and not the 100-point game.” There are commenters who believe it’s “insane” that we have a lot of footage of World War II and none of Wilt Chamberlain’s 100-point game. And this is suspicious… somehow. It’s actually a brainless take. Yes, we have footage of the deadliest, most important conflict in the history of humanity, which lasted over five years, but we don’t have footage of a random basketball game in Hershey, Pennsylvania during a time when almost no NBA games were filmed. It’s not crazy at all.
There’s a temporally illogical belief at the core of this, which is that, because the 100-point game is historically significant, it should have been filmed. Yeah, people generally film historic things if we can. But you would only know the game is historic AFTER it happened. It’s not like Wilt went around a week before saying, “Hey by the way guys, next Friday I’m gonna drop a hundred points on those sorry-ass Knicks.” It just happened.
Just think about it for more than five seconds. The game was not in Madison Square Garden. It wasn’t even in the Philadelphia Convention Hall. It was in Hershey, a town 95 miles away from Philadelphia. Why? Because the NBA was so unpopular that they were trying to garner fans from non-major cities. It was towards the end of the season, and the Warriors had no chance of catching the Celtics for the #1 seed, and the Knicks were completely out of the playoff picture. Even for an unpopular league [at the time], it was a particularly unappealing game.
And yet, Wilt Chamberlain was the greatest basketball player for one game, setting the game’s most famous record. It’s certainly Wilt’s most famous one, and ironically it’s one of the more breakable ones for the Big Dipper. No one’s touching 27 RPG, 48.5 MPG, or 50 PPG for a season. But someone could surpass Wilt in a single game.
1 4-round playoff run: Hakeem Olajuwon
In 1994, the Houston Rockets were the 2nd seed in the western conference, so naturally they faced the 7th seed Portland Trail Blazers. Olajuwon led every game in scoring, including a dominant 46-point, 6-block performance in game 2. It perfectly showcased his excellence on both offense and defense. They quickly dispensed with the Blazers.
In the second round, the Rockets faced the Phoenix Suns, led by Charles Barkley. It was a back-and-forth, seven game series between the two contenders. This included a 36-point, 16-rebound, 5-assist, 3-block performance in game 1, and game 7 statline of 37 points, 17 rebounds, 5 assists, and 3 blocks. Amazing stuff. All-around greatness. He helped clinch the series and he proved that he was worthy of that year’s MVP award. I know, it’s a regular season award, but you always like to see the winner do well in the playoffs.
Hakeem continued his dominance in the western conference finals against the Stockton/Malone Jazz. Unsurprisingly, Olajuwon had more amazing performances. It’s easy to just list the statlines again, and they’re remarkable, but you gotta just watch Olajuwon to appreciate his greatness. He had so many post moves, his presence on defense was undeniable, and his basketball I.Q. was top-notch.
In the NBA finals, the Rockets faced off against the New York Knicks. It was one of those finals matchups where the best player on each team played the same position. Patrick Ewing was probably the 4th best center in the league at a time which was rife with great centers. But as the finals played out, it became abundantly clear that Olajuwon was #1, and Ewing was #4.
Hakeem’s averages were fairly comparable to his MVP regular season, but Ewing’s dropped significantly due to Olajuwon’s stifling defense. His scoring fell by 5.6 points per game, and his shooting percentage fell by 13.5% to an abysmal 36.3% from the field. Hakeem Olajuwon was clearly the best player on the court, and proved himself the best basketball player for a four-round playoff run.
Side note: the broadcast of game 5 of the finals series was interrupted by footage of some guy driving a white Ford Bronco down the 405 freeway. Odd.
1 season: Shaquille O’Neal
Many great basketball players have had many great seasons. Even I had a great season in 11th grade. I was awesome out there. It was must-see high school basketball, in my parents’ opinion. But I wasn’t the greatest basketball player for one season. That was Shaquille O’Neal in the 1999-2000 NBA season.
Now am I biased because Shaq is my favorite player and the Lakers are my favorite team and the early 2000s was my favorite era of basketball? No. I’m not biased. I’m the first non-biased, perfectly objective sports opinion writer who’s ever lived. It’s an amazing feeling.
So Shaq was objectively the greatest player for a season. He thoroughly dominated the game of basketball. It was not just that every team knew he was the best player, though that was true. Teams were lost about what to do with him. Should we double team him? Triple team him? Double team him without the ball? Front him? Foul him? How often? There was no true answer because he was just that dominant. That’s why, when we talk about all-time hypothetical matchups between historic teams, or imaginary teams, you always hear the same refrain: who’s guarding Shaq?
Shaq’s dominance culminated on his 28th birthday, when he scored 61 points, grabbed 23 rebounds, and shot 68.6% from the field. It was a joy to watch this season, to watch the greatest basketball player for one season.
5 years: Michael Jordan
Michael Jordan had the greatest 5-year stretch of any basketball player ever. The only challenge is picking between the 88-92 stretch or the 89-93 stretch. In 88, he won MVP and Defensive Player of the Year, but awards are just awards. People vote on them. They’re not handed down by God on stone tablets. We often use NBA awards to boost our arguments, then disparage the awards/voters when we don’t like them. When Kareem has 6 MVP’s, that makes him the greatest center, but when Shaq and Kobe only have 1 MVP each, that means that the awards and voters are stupid. It’s awesome.
Anyway, from the 1988/89 season through the 1992/93 season, Michael Jordan was the greatest basketball player over a five year period. He led the NBA every one of those years in win shares, VORP, and PER, if you care about those things. He also led the league every year in points per game, which is a much more understandable statistic. A player plays a certain number of games, they score a certain number of points, then you take the points and divide that number by the number of games. There you go!
Late 80s/early 90s Michael Jordan had an incredible combination of skill and athleticism. He would fly through the air. He would make acrobatic, contested layups. He had the midrange. He led the league in steals per game in two of those years. His first step was lethal. His competitive drive was legendary, as we all know. He took things PERSONALLY. It’s an interesting quality because, in general, if someone takes everything very personally and gets offended by incredibly minor things, that’s not typically considered to be a good quality. In fact, it’s often considered to a non-masculine quality. BUT if you then kick everyone’s ass at basketball, it cancels out.
And of course the Jordan-led Bulls won 3 straight NBA championships, and he gave three of the greatest finals performances ever. In 91, he averaged 31.2 points and 11.4 assists per game which is just absurd. Only Magic Johnson has ever had more assists per game in a finals series. It’s crazy to think about, considering how many great point guards/passers/assist-getters have played in the finals. Magic has the highest six spots, then the scorer Michael Jordan, not Isiah Thomas or Bob Cousy or Oscar Robertson or Walt Frazier or John Stockton or Jason Kidd or Lebron James or Chris Paul. Wild.
In 92, he torched Drexler in the head-to-head matchup, and in 93, he set the still-standing finals record for points per game with 41. The three-peat was complete with MJ earning the finals MVP each time, obviously. He only won the regular season MVP twice in this five year period, but he was the best basketball player in the world throughout the entire five-year period. The NBA MVP award is a strange one.
Oh yeah, he also won an Olympic gold medal as the leader of the Dream Team [though Barkley did lead the team in points per game]. They totally dominated the international competition, winning by an average of 43.75 points over the course of their 8 games.
MJ had the prolific scoring, the amazing defense, the dominant playoff performances, great handles, great finishing, and great passing when he needed to. He had the greatest 5 years of basketball.
1 lifetime: Lebron James
Lebron James was born in Akron, Ohio, just outside of Cleveland, on December 30th, 1984. That was just a few days after Michael Jordan torched the Cleveland Cavaliers for 45 points. Not sure why I bring that up. It’s not like the two players need to be compared incessantly. They’re just two NBA players among many. We can compare and contrast any of them.
Anyway, as Lebron began his high school basketball career, quickly became a phenom, a savant, a wunderkind of basketball. At the time, there were some straight-outta-high-school players who were achieving success in the NBA, notably Kobe Bryant and Kevin Garnett. It’s been speculated that Lebron may have been the #1 overall pick after his junior year of high school. Junior year! I was in some middle school “competitive” leagues back then and we all talked about him like we were fantasy RPG characters in a small town waiting for the hero to come and fulfill the prophecy. Sports Illustrated even crowned him the “Chosen One” in February of 2002. That was when he was a 17 year-old JUNIOR in high school. There was so much hype. The best NBA players in the world, like Shaquille O’Neal, were attending Lebron’s high school games.
He entered the league as the #1 pick for the hometown Cleveland Cavaliers. He and Carmelo Anthony both won the rookie of the month award every month for their respective conferences, and Lebron won the rookie of the year. He quickly became one of the game’s best players, and came in 2nd place in the highly contested 2006 MVP race. In 2007, at 22 years old, he put on a masterful performance against the mighty, defense-oriented Pistons. He was totally unstoppable, scoring 25 straight Cavalier points in the 4th quarter and overtime, making a game-tying dunk to send the game into another overtime and a game-winning layup in the second overtime period.
Lebron’s first stint in Cleveland was characterized by his incredible, Herculean efforts with a subpar supporting cast. The Cavs were never able to secure a true co-star for him. Even the big names they did sign [like Shaquille O’Neal and Ben Wallace] were well past their prime. It’s almost like great NBA players don’t really want to live/play in Cleveland, Ohio.
Speaking of which, Lebron left Cleveland, Ohio with 2 MVP’s under his belt and headed to Miami. There he won 2 more MVP’s, 2 championships, and 2 Finals MVP’s. His 2013 season was one of the best ever, a perfect mix of athleticism, IQ, and skill. Upon his return to Cleveland, fans, players, and analysts began to ask, “How long can he keep playing at an elite level?” and they’re still asking that 10 years later.
Anyway, in 2015, he had yet another great season. This time he was teamed up with Kyrie Irving and Kevin Love. Both were better teammates than he ever had in his first stint in Cleveland. Naturally, they did pretty well in the playoffs. Unfortunately, in game 4 of a 1st-round sweep, Celtics forward Kelly Olynyk hooked Love’s arm and ripped out his shoulder. In game 1 of the finals against the Warriors, Kyrie Irving suffered a fractured kneecap and was ruled out for the rest of the series. Not great. The Warriors won the series, but Lebron did receive some votes for finals MVP.
Lebron had another great season in 2016, with similar stats to his 2015 campaign. The Cavs swept the Pistons, then swept the Hawks. In the conference finals, the Cavs beat the Toronto Raptors, which was very common in Lebron’s second stint in Cleveland. As we all know, they faced the Warriors in the finals again. That Warriors team had just won 73 out of 82 games [an NBA record], they had the only unanimous MVP, Steph Curry, and they were considered one of the greatest teams of all time. Predictably, the Warriors went up 3-1 in the series.
No team had ever come back from a 3-1 deficit in the NBA finals. Teams in that situation were 0-32 at that point. It seemed incredibly unlikely that the first such comeback would be against a 73-9 team with the unanimous MVP and 2 games at home. Yet, in game 5, Lebron scored 41 points on 53% shooting, grabbed 16 boards, dished 7 assists, got 3 steals and 3 blocks in a do-or-die situation. But hey, Draymond Green was suspended [that’s what Draymond Green does], so that probably won’t happen in game 6 right? Actually it was the same story. James had another 41-point night, with 8 rebounds, 11 assists, 4 steals and 3 blocks, on 59% shooting. And in game 7, among other things, Lebron had the greatest, most clutch block in the history of basketball, preventing an Andre Iguodala layup. The Cavs completed the comeback, and Lebron led both teams in all 5 major statistical categories. He proved that, even though he wasn’t the MVP, he was still the best basketball player on the planet, which happened with several MVP winners.
As we all know, Kevin Durant joined that 73-9 Warriors team in the off-season, creating the greatest “super team” of all time. The two teams met up in the finals the next 2 years, with Lebron producing some of the greatest finals averages ever, but falling to the overpowered Warriors. One stat that encapsulates these finals is that in game 3 of the 2017 finals, Lebron James played 46 minutes. In those 46 minutes, the Cavs outscored the Warriors by 7 points. In the 2 minutes that Lebron was on the bench, the Cavs were outscored by 12, ultimately losing the game by 5.
During his time with the Lakers, Lebron has experienced a slow but steady decline. He’s still an elite player, but not quite as good as he was in 2013, which is 11 years ago now. That being said, his longevity is unprecedented. His scoring at 39 is way above anyone else at 39. His scoring in his 21st season is miles ahead of anyone else in their 21st season. He became the 2nd oldest finals MVP in 2020. Lebron is the NBA’s all-time leading scorer and the only player to score 40,000 points in the NBA. Lebron’s basketball career speaks for itself.
But wait a minute… he kinda sucked in the 2011 Finals. Remember that? You know what, never mind. The greatest basketball player for a lifetime is actually Kareem Abdul-Jabbar.